Anonymous1: While I'm glad to see art of the more conventionally attractive women who were characters in Campaign 1, those faces leave much to be desired. Especially Pike's bimbo lips. Ugh.
Anonymous5: @Anonymous: By that logic, how can you chastise my opinion? After all, if I have to post my own art to criticize the art of others, then by extension, you have to post your own art to defend the art of others. After all, your argument is based on the notion that a creation can only be commented on by fellow creators. "Either put up or shut up Anon."
By the way, professional art critics are very rarely artists themselves. Movie critics almost never have any film-making experience. And theatre critics rarely have set foot on a stage as an actor. Critique does not require contribution to the field. Besides, as once said by Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw - a video game critic with minimal video game development experience - "The worst thing you can do to an artist is tell them their work is good when it's not."
Anonymous6: @TwistedR: Agreed. Ultimately, it really doesn't matter when the artist appears to just consistently stick to this sort of cartoony style. I'm not saying that it's good or bad, it's meh, OR using style to justify the way the art looks, but I highly doubt the artist intends to deviate from this approach and is probably making these for fun or as a hobby or something without caring about critiques or self-improvement.
Anonymous8: If You look at a picture of Pike they always keep on the Talks Machina set, the lips will make more sense.
That is all I have to say one way or the other.
By the way, professional art critics are very rarely artists themselves. Movie critics almost never have any film-making experience. And theatre critics rarely have set foot on a stage as an actor. Critique does not require contribution to the field. Besides, as once said by Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw - a video game critic with minimal video game development experience - "The worst thing you can do to an artist is tell them their work is good when it's not."
- Reply
I personally don't care for Pike's design here at all either, but I think Keyleth is pretty great.
That is all I have to say one way or the other.