Titus: and here we have yet another faggot who thinks that not being able to draw precludes one from commenting on the art of others. if there were the case, no one would be allowed to have an opinion on anything that they couldn't do at least as well.
can't cook? well, no matter how bad your food tastes, no complaining.
can't direct a movie? then you can't say anything about how bad the star wars prequel trilogy or the new indiana jones movie is.
You have a point, that is the point of a third grader who doesn't like to be told his opinion doesn't matter. Crybabies tend to critique but have nothing to show.
Ever heard of the phrase "Put up or shut up"? No you don't; if you did, you would have reason for liking or disliking something. You don't have any specific reasons in design or artistic terminology to back up your argument, therefore you have no basis for not liking other than being a "troll" as you say. Just because you CAN open your mouth doesn't mean you should, and unless you have a valid reason for criticizing, you can't just say whether or not something's bad or good. Didn't they teach you that in school? Grow up, mate.
Critics only have credibility because they know what it's like to participate in their field. You however merely have the critique: I don't like it! That's nothing.
An answer to your question, yes. You cannot critique unless you can in some way perform or prove that your opinion is credible by experience. Period.
biggerstaff: A6: You don't need to be an expert to realize that some things are made of shit and fail. Look at Twilight, or the Eragon movie. I don't need to be an author/director to know that they suck.
Of course, some things don't fall under that category. Like this - I don't really see anything wrong with it. It's just more generic art to me, and without drawing any of my own, I can't say how good/bad it is.
Titus: Who said anything about critiquing, dipshit? I never claimed that I was making an objective analysis of this pic based on my vast knowledge of the field. I was responding to your bullshit position that if you aren't an expert in a field, you can't comment on it. That's all this ever was, asshole: my opinion. I don't need to be a skilled artist to have an opinion on what styles I find displeasing, and I don't need your approval to express my opinion. That's kind of the point of comment systems--expressing one's opinion.
But you don't care about that. You're just a butthurt little bitch who tries to use elitist bullshit to shut up people he disagrees with.
HitodamaKyrie: Titus, you can say your opinion all you want, but you still sound like a dick. I don't give a damn what art you like, so why are the comments full of fucking bitching?
Anonymous9(3): Hey Titus, do you realize that you actually DO need his approval.
Ya know, when you answer somebody's comment your basically defending yourself and proving your opinion is valid to the other person.
If you really didn't care, you wouldn't keep posting on a friggin' porno site. But you DO care, so you actually DO need his approval. That be really sad bro.
BTW: Anon 6 may be a pretentious dick, but you sound more butthurt to me, and more of a crybaby. Sounds like someone hasn't had their bottle filled today!
VwX: Uh hey every, shut the fuck up and fap if you like it, if you don't just get the fuck out and don't comment on the pictures bad enough the mods would deal with senseless arguements or pointless comments.
Anonymous10: This is one of the better Starfire drawings, but I wish her skin matched the color of the series better. Right now she looks like a boring, generic caucasian.
Big talk for someone with no art. Let's see your shit.
can't cook? well, no matter how bad your food tastes, no complaining.
can't direct a movie? then you can't say anything about how bad the star wars prequel trilogy or the new indiana jones movie is.
now doesn't that seem a tad bit stupid?
You have a point, that is the point of a third grader who doesn't like to be told his opinion doesn't matter. Crybabies tend to critique but have nothing to show.
Ever heard of the phrase "Put up or shut up"? No you don't; if you did, you would have reason for liking or disliking something. You don't have any specific reasons in design or artistic terminology to back up your argument, therefore you have no basis for not liking other than being a "troll" as you say. Just because you CAN open your mouth doesn't mean you should, and unless you have a valid reason for criticizing, you can't just say whether or not something's bad or good. Didn't they teach you that in school? Grow up, mate.
Critics only have credibility because they know what it's like to participate in their field. You however merely have the critique: I don't like it! That's nothing.
An answer to your question, yes. You cannot critique unless you can in some way perform or prove that your opinion is credible by experience. Period.
i suck yo dick?
Of course, some things don't fall under that category. Like this - I don't really see anything wrong with it. It's just more generic art to me, and without drawing any of my own, I can't say how good/bad it is.
But you don't care about that. You're just a butthurt little bitch who tries to use elitist bullshit to shut up people he disagrees with.
Ya know, when you answer somebody's comment your basically defending yourself and proving your opinion is valid to the other person.
If you really didn't care, you wouldn't keep posting on a friggin' porno site. But you DO care, so you actually DO need his approval. That be really sad bro.
BTW: Anon 6 may be a pretentious dick, but you sound more butthurt to me, and more of a crybaby. Sounds like someone hasn't had their bottle filled today!
- Reply
- Reply