Anonymous1: Hmmmm,well If you watched the show, you could tell that she is Amy, the new companion. Zimmerman isn't a bad artist, you're just a fucking Idiot.
craggle: so in other words you CAN'T tell that this is amy if you watched the show?
because a1 said that if you watched the show, you could tell this is amy, and only fucking idiots couldn't tell it. so if that's the case, a1 and a2 should be able to point to distinguishing features that indicate this is amy.
red hair's hard to portray in a black and white drawing. so is blonde hair. if you decide the hair is blonde, this might as well be rose. and even if you decide the hair is red, it could be donna. one way even zimmerman occasionally is able to distinguish characters is through costumes or props that are unique to the character, but that doesn't work here since she's not in costume.
so, if a2 is a1, how can you tell it's amy, and not some other girl, without psychic knowledge of what the hair color is in a black and white drawing?
craggle: unfortunately, zimmerman doesn't have the best track record at making different characters looking different. for cartoon characters, he's okay, but for real people, he's woefully inadequete.
what exactly are the distinguishing features here that suggest this is amy and not anybody else?
because a1 said that if you watched the show, you could tell this is amy, and only fucking idiots couldn't tell it. so if that's the case, a1 and a2 should be able to point to distinguishing features that indicate this is amy.
red hair's hard to portray in a black and white drawing. so is blonde hair. if you decide the hair is blonde, this might as well be rose. and even if you decide the hair is red, it could be donna. one way even zimmerman occasionally is able to distinguish characters is through costumes or props that are unique to the character, but that doesn't work here since she's not in costume.
so, if a2 is a1, how can you tell it's amy, and not some other girl, without psychic knowledge of what the hair color is in a black and white drawing?
Personally I thought of Amy when I saw it, but on closer inspection it could easily be Rose... I still think it's Amy though :)
Let the Amy tag be placed!
It's hot